ST.
LOUIS — John Mozeliak, the president of baseball operations for the Cardinals, has built a strong reputation for bringing in top-tier talent, having added players like Paul Goldschmidt, Willson Contreras, and Nolan Arenado to the roster.
This offseason, however, presents a set of unique hurdles that have caused the team’s plans to unfold more gradually than expected.
Trade Talks and Future Plans
At the heart of this delay lies the ongoing discussions surrounding Nolan Arenado, a three-time All-Star and ten-time Gold Glove winner.
Arenado, who has three years left on his contract totaling $74 million, exercised his no-trade clause to turn down a proposed deal with the Astros back in December.
Since then, negotiations haven’t resulted in an agreement that satisfies all parties involved.
Mozeliak noted that the team’s efforts toward a significant roster “reset” for the 2025 season hinge on the resolution of Arenado’s future.
While he remains hopeful about the possibility of a trade, Mozeliak admits that gauging the situation is tricky.
Nevertheless, the organization is prioritizing the exploration of trade options in hopes of improving financial flexibility and creating space for younger players to develop within the team.
Shifts in Roster Composition
The Cardinals are traditionally known for their competitive spirit and dedication to vying for pennants.
However, after finishing the previous season with a record of 83-79, they are embarking on a strategic transformation this year.
With anticipated drops in revenue stemming from declining television contracts and potential fluctuations in game attendance, the franchise is making bold moves to trim payroll.
This includes parting ways with veterans such as Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson, as well as allowing Goldschmidt to depart through free agency.
In contrast, players like Sonny Gray and Contreras have opted to stay with the Cardinals despite possessing no-trade clauses, demonstrating their commitment to the franchise’s future.
Meanwhile, Arenado’s desire for a new opportunity creates a more complicated dynamic.
At 33, his recent drop in power production adds further challenges to any potential trades.
Outlook for the 2025 Season
Although Mozeliak hasn’t completely ruled out the possibility of Arenado joining the team for Spring Training in Jupiter, Florida, starting February 17, the organization is keen to prevent that scenario from materializing.
He emphasizes that while the current situation may appear stagnant, patience is critical as they work through these complexities, acknowledging that the path forward isn’t solely in their hands.
Gray voiced his surprise at the Cardinals’ shift towards a rebuilding phase, especially given the team’s strong contender history.
Yet, he’s eager to remain with the squad, focusing on building relationships with teammates and the front office.
He believes the Cardinals have the potential to surpass expectations in the upcoming season.
According to Gray, the roster is filled with talent, and younger players need opportunities to step into their roles.
Veteran players like him see their role as one of mentorship, encouraging the next wave of talent to flourish.
Brendan Donovan, an integral part of a promising young core alongside emerging talents like Masyn Winn and Jordan Walker, is optimistic about retaining both Gray and Contreras.
He views the combination of youthful enthusiasm and experienced leadership as a recipe for potential success.
Donovan believes that these transitional moments are more about growth than setbacks and sees a bright future ahead.
As the team contemplates any roster changes, the outcome of Arenado’s situation remains pivotal.
Mozeliak is committed to finding a suitable destination for the star player while also recognizing the unique dynamics of the current roster.
He underscores the importance of resilience as they navigate this chapter, always seeking the most beneficial path for the team’s future.
