Does a Fielder’s Choice Count as a Hit? Understanding Baseball Scoring Rules

Understanding Fielder’s Choice in Baseball

As you delve into baseball’s intricate rules, understanding what constitutes a fielder’s choice is essential.

This aspect of the game significantly impacts how plays are scored and how players’ batting statistics are evaluated.

Fielder’s Choice Defined

A fielder’s choice occurs when a fielder handles a batted ball but opts to put out another runner instead of the batter.

Essentially, if there are runners on base and the hitter puts the ball in play, an infielder — often the shortstop or second baseman — may decide it’s easier or more strategic to get an out at another base rather than striving for the out at first base.

Even if the batter is safe due to this choice, it does not count as a hit. Understanding The Rules And Strategies

Impact on Batting Statistics

When a batter reaches base due to a fielder’s choice, it doesn’t boost their on-base percentage (OBP) because it’s not counted as a hit.

The official scorer will record it as a fielder’s choice, granting the batter an at-bat without crediting them with a hit.

In your average game, how plays like these are scored can subtly influence a player’s statistics. A Complete Guide

Common Scenarios Involving a Fielder’s Choice

Common scenarios where you might see a fielder’s choice include situations where infielders decide to get an extra base to tag out a leading baserunner.

Other instances could involve potential double plays where the defensive team opts to get an initial force out at second base but the hitter reaches first base safely.

Moreover, a fielder’s choice isn’t just limited to outs; if the defensive player makes an error or if there’s indifference on a stolen base attempt, these can also lead to a fielder’s choice being called by the scorekeeper. What Is a Fielder’s Choice in Baseball?

The Official Scorer’s Role and Scoring Plays

When you watch a baseball game, every play that unfolds is meticulously documented.

The official scorer plays a pivotal role in this record-keeping, particularly when deciding whether a play is recorded as a hit or a fielder’s choice, among others, influencing stats like the batting average and RBIs.

The Role of an Official Scorer in Baseball

An official scorer in baseball has the task of making judgement calls on plays that can impact a player’s statistics.

Your understanding of the game’s intricacies depends on their decisions.

The scorer uses a set of guidelines, like those detailed in MLB Rule 2, to determine the nature of a play.

For instance, they decide whether a batter’s advancement to first base is a result of a hit, an error, or a fielder’s choice (FC).

This distinction is vital, as it affects a player’s batting average and can even influence the momentum, or rally, of the inning.

Recording Hits and Fielder’s Choices

When a batter puts the ball into play, and reaches base without the benefit of an error or a fielder’s choice, this is typically recorded as a safe hit.

However, if the batter reaches base because the defense aims to put out another runner, it’s noted as a “FC.” For example, during a 6-4-3 double play attempt, if the lead runner is thrown out but the batter reaches first safely, the scorer records this as a fielder’s choice, not a hit.

Errors vs. Fielder’s Choices

Contrasting errors and fielder’s choices can be tricky, but here’s the rundown: an error is scored when a defensive player’s misplay allows a batter or runner to reach a base they would not have reached with ordinary effort.

In contrast, a fielder’s choice is marked when a fielder opts to try for a different putout rather than targeting the batter-runner.

If, for example, the third baseman chooses to go for a putout at third, allowing the batter to reach first, the scorer records it as a fielder’s choice.

This crucial call does not penalize the batter’s skill, as with an error, but rather reflects the strategic defensive play that prioritizes preventing a run from scoring over the batter-runner’s advancement.

One comment

  1. Ah, the good ol’ fielder’s choice, making baseball stats even more confusing than they already are. Gotta love it!

Comments are closed.